Madden NFL 19 Review - IGN (2024)

Madden 19

Madden NFL 19 builds a new foundation for the football franchise.

ByDustin Toms

Updated:

Apr 21, 2020 1:07 am

Posted:

Aug 2, 2018 4:00 am

Madden NFL 19 keeps its focus where it belongs: its moment-to-moment gameplay. This year’s entry comes with the promise of improved player motion, a more intimate franchise experience, and the return of two hometown heroes as the Longshot story continues with a new chapter.But does Madden ‘19 have the balance needed to stay between the uprights and keep both newcomers and long-time Madden fans happy? In short: Yes, yes it does.

Every IGN Madden NFL Game Review Ever

A Beautiful Game

In a surprisingly - yet welcomed - straight-forward call, Real Player Motion is touted as the marquee gameplay enhancement and allows more control in game-changing situations. In year two of the series’ move to the Frostbite engine, it’s apparent the development team is learning how to maximize the technology.You can see that growth on display in the excellent fluidity your players bring to the field. Basic moves like spins, jukes, and the ability to adjust your speed and hit the gap all look fantastic. It’s a noticeable improvement that you will see across speed changes, cuts, and tackling with crushing blows when you hit the Truck Stick.

The feel of the game continues to improve, especially with Madden 19’s enhanced controls. You’ll see your stick talent translate on screen in fluid motions that’ll have you pumping your first in the air while you beat down your friends. And it’s not just what you see while playing on offense juking and spinning your way to a touchdown. On both sides of the ball, player interactions have gotten a noticeable bump from last year. It’s the way a defensive lineman can break off a tackle to crush the halfback in the backfield. The way safeties can track down the ball and pick it off before momentum carries them out of bounds. And the way play action breaks down as the edge blitz catches you off guard, nearly causing you to jump in fear. EA has done a great job capturing the speed, momentum, and impact of football in Madden 19.

The power of the engine combined with the PS4 Pro (and likely Xbox One X) is a sight to see. Madden’s visuals and that player movement look better than the series has ever known. The graphical push in this year’s offering is amazing, and player models (for those that are in the game) look more realistic than ever in both the menus and on the field. In short, not only does Madden 19 feel great to play, it’s great to to look at, too.

Live Your Best Franchise

EA has finally added customization options to Madden 19, allowing the Madden community to create their own draft classes. This sorely missed mechanic adds a new layer of realism to the season-long experience. After you advance to week 3 of your season, these draft classes can be saved and shared with the community, encouraging all fans to download realistic classes with some of college football’s most notable athletes. You can even edit players after the draft class has been uploaded.

EA has finally added Franchise customization options to Madden 19.

This new feature let me feel more connected to my team – a point I sincerely appreciate considering how much time I spend with it on and off the field. And with 450 roster spots in each draft class, you can be sure roster projects will start spreading across online forums in search of the perfect draft class that will become a go to addition for every Franchise mode player.

Additionally, Franchise mode has also introduced offensive and defensive schemes this time around. And while diehard football fans may not see the benefit in this, casual players may appreciate the assistance as schemes help highlight the best players in trades, free agency, and the draft for you particular scheme.

A simple change from one scheme to another can drastically alter your team’s play. In my Titans franchise, I swapped from a Tamp 2 (42% scheme fit) to a 46 (92%) without needing to alter my roster. Specialty positions such as slot cornerback and slot wide receiver are now included in your team’s depth chart too, giving you more options for fine tuning.

Free Agency and the Draft seem largely untouched this year. The Madden series has yet to find a perfect process for keeping free agency engaging, but its draft process is in a great comfort zone which will only get better as the draft class creation starts ramping up.

An Untouched Gem

Madden Ultimate Team continues its formula of collecting cards and fielding a roster to compete against opponents online. The biggest new addition in Madden 19 are the solo challenge tournaments that offer up new opportunities to play – this time against teams created by Madden developers, NFL athletes, and celebrities – creating another strong vein of content in the mode. And with a leaderboard system built in, there’s a great opportunity to dabble in an esports-adjacent environment.

A new wrinkle in Ultimate Team this year requires you to upgrade players to fit your team’s mold, and the more you play the more you can upgrade. The downside is that this will likely become the new grind of the Madden franchise, however it’s mitigated by the fact you can downgrade those same players to refund resources you’ve invested if you want to go another way. It is cool how you can grow your best player rated in the late 60s up to a potential 90. For those of you who have trouble throwing anything away, this may be the best fit for you.

In complete transparency, I’m not a frequent visitor to Ultimate Team, but it’s a mode that rises and falls with gameplay. These new ways to play Madden’s most popular mode will most definitely be a hit to fans of the collectible mode.

Devin and Colt Return

In Madden 19 EA has doubled down on one the best features of Madden 18 – The Longshot Story mode. It’s a direct sequel to the storyline from last year, this time dubbed Longshot: Homecoming, which follows the struggles of Devin Wade and Colt Cruise as they navigate the NFL and their personal lives.

This second slice of the Devin and Colt show feels forced.

Devin continues to battle his play-calling woes, showing nice continuity from last season’s story, as Colt endeavors to land a tryout or his next hit song. The mode does put a larger focus on including gameplay this time, but it simply feels like an excuse to run a drill that you’re required to pass to proceed. It becomes more of an annoyance than anything to “Try Again."

Unfortunately, this second slice of the Devin and Colt show feels forced and cliché. It left me feeling like the opportunity to build something special was wasted. Despite its brisk three-hour runtime, it’s still a few hours I wish I could get back.

Verdict

Madden 19 returns the primary focus where it belongs: that moment-to-moment gameplay between the end zones. It’s only true stumbling point is the lackluster story mode that fails to recapture the magic of the first, but that's entirely offset by the new player handling that once again leverages the power of the Frostbite engine. Most importantly, Madden 19 has finally cracked that slightly repetitive feel that can make it tough to go on, game after game. With Real Player Motion delivering a fluid on-the-field experience, and Franchise mode customization offering another level of realism, Madden is in a great place.

In This Article

Madden NFL 19 Review - IGN (1)

Madden NFL 19

EA Tiburon

ESRB: Everyone
Xbox OnePlayStation 4PC

Related Guides

OverviewTeam RatingsTop 20 Players by Position

Madden NFL 19 Review

great

Madden NFL 19 finds a new foundation for football gameplay on the back of its feel-good player handling.

Madden NFL 19 Review - IGN (2)

Madden NFL 19 Review - IGN (2024)

FAQs

Is Madden 19 a good game? ›

Overall, Madden NFL 19 is a fantastic addition to the franchise and a true testament to the technological advancements made in the gaming industry.

Why was Madden 20 so good? ›

Player Development Feels More Meaningful in Franchise

In Madden 20, it's one of the best aspects of a franchise mode that is still lacking in a number of areas. Again, the storytelling element is present. Your players have different development traits, and many of them can add more throughout their career.

Is Madden NFL 20 worth it? ›

Customers like the quality of the video game. They mention that it's a great game, fun, and exciting. They also say that the graphics get better every year, the card system is fun, the games are competitive, and there are plenty of game modes to keep things interesting. Customers appreciate the value of the game.

How old is Madden 19? ›

Madden NFL 19
SeriesMadden NFL
EngineFrostbite 3
Platform(s)PlayStation 4 Xbox One Windows
ReleaseAugust 10, 2018
8 more rows

Is Madden 19 discontinued? ›

Alongside this announcement, EA has also confirmed it will close the servers of Madden NFL 18 and Madden NFL 19 on March 7th, 2023.

What is the most fun Madden game? ›

Featuring Marshall Faulk on the cover, Madden NFL 2003 sits with a 95 as the best Madden NFL game according to Metacritic. Many reviews of the game gave it a perfect score, often praising the strong gameplay mechanics and variety of modes that players could choose from.

How good was Madden 18? ›

Madden 18 is the best installment of the series in the last years. Very solid and with stunning graphics thanks to the Frostbite engine. Great both for the veterans of the genre and for the newcomers.

Has Madden ever had a 100 rating? ›

For two years there were players who were given a 100 overall rating, but Madden quickly took that feature out. The only players to be named to the 100 Club were Barry Sanders, Jerry Rice, Shannon Sharpe, Mark Chmura, Tony Boselli, Mike Alstott and Deion Sanders spread out form Madden 1999 and Madden 2000.

Is Madden 20 shutting down? ›

Highlights. Two EA games are shutting down in April 2024, including Kim Kardashian: Hollywood and Madden NFL 20. Fans have advance notice of these shutdowns, giving them time to enjoy the games before the online components disappear.

Is Madden 15 or 25 better? ›

That said, Madden 15 clearly improved from a graphical standpoint as it compares to Madden 25. Lighting, uniforms and body types look better. There are more real player faces in the game than before, and players who once had head-scratching complexions seem to have been corrected.

Does playing Madden make you a better football player? ›

Kotaku has observed that Madden does indeed work. In a 2009 article the gaming website noted a study by the University of Oregon that discovered those who played Madden had a 60% higher football IQ than those who didn't. Everything from history to technical decisions and plays were elevated for Madden players.

Who won Madden 19? ›

Drini Gjoka Wins the Madden 19 Bowl.

Are Madden 16 servers still up? ›

Madden 16 will no longer have online after 11/19/2020.

How old was John Madden at death? ›

Death. Madden died of undisclosed causes at his home in Pleasanton, California, on December 28, 2021, at the age of 85.

What is the best rated Madden? ›

The List: Best Madden Games, According to Experts
  • Madden NFL 2004. Topping the list of the best Madden games is none other than Madden 2004, or Madden '04. ...
  • Madden NFL 2005. Next up on the list of the best games in the franchise is Madden 2005. ...
  • Madden NFL 2003. ...
  • Madden NFL 2007. ...
  • Madden NFL 2010.
Sep 6, 2023

Should I play 2K or Madden? ›

Madden seems to make realistic gameplay as the top priority over everything else. So all other features/elements feel like a “bolt on”, and not well integrated. The 2K approach is more holistic. It's an integration between lifestyle and gameplay as a unit, not as a secondary afterthought.

What is the best Madden play? ›

What is the best Madden 24 pass play? The best pass play available in Madden 24 is the PA Y Cross play. This comes from the Kansas City Chiefs offensive playbook (Andy Reid is great at designing offensive plays and Madden knows that) in the Shotgun formations Normal Off Close Wk, one of the best formations.

What team is good in Madden 19? ›

Team Ratings
PositionTeamOVR
1Philadelphia Eagles91
2Pittsburgh Steelers86
3New England Patriots85
4Atlanta Falcons84
28 more rows

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Sen. Ignacio Ratke

Last Updated:

Views: 5756

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (56 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Sen. Ignacio Ratke

Birthday: 1999-05-27

Address: Apt. 171 8116 Bailey Via, Roberthaven, GA 58289

Phone: +2585395768220

Job: Lead Liaison

Hobby: Lockpicking, LARPing, Lego building, Lapidary, Macrame, Book restoration, Bodybuilding

Introduction: My name is Sen. Ignacio Ratke, I am a adventurous, zealous, outstanding, agreeable, precious, excited, gifted person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.